Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Canberra Comment 
 Australian quarantine running a fever 

Australian quarantine running a fever

The latest disease to hit Australian shores raises more concerns about Australia's quarantine and the risk of human error.

It's getting close to a week since Australian horses started to cough, splutter and sniffle with the devastating symptoms of equine influenza, yet nobody will answer who or what brought the disease to Australia, how it got here and why it presumably spread out of a Sydney quarantine station.

If this was foot and mouth disease, we'd be in a bit of trouble by now, and there's a real feeling of deja vu when you start thinking back to events like citrus canker, or "that" Brazilian beef episode at the Wagga Wagga tip.

The Federal Government won't admit that Australia's quarantine system has failed, despite a nation's horse industry in lock down to contain a disease not seen in Australia before.

The disease's economic impact is already tipped to run into the billions and the calls for compensation and threats of litigation are starting to surface.

The whole case wreaks of human error, and the credibility Australia's quarantine protocols are looking weak with fever.

Minister for Agriculture, Peter McGauran, said authorities first became aware that horses in quarantine were displaying EI symptoms on August 17.

Yet the first publicity of the disease in Australia only surfaced last Thursday afternoon.

On Wednesday last week, Mr McGauran actually played down concerns about the impact of a potential disease outbreak by simply saying "it ain't coming in here".

Now that it's here, he's still to answer exactly what this disease is doing in Australia in the first place, with protocols requiring horses from Japan are kept in the same place for two months immediately prior to export in Japan on a property where there has been no trace of the disease for three months.

Not only has the system let us down at our borders, but also inside out borders.

Who is going to take the wrap so that the same "human errors" don't let something equally as devastating, like a bird flu or foot and mouth disease, into our country?

If it's anything like our past quarantine blunders, probably no one.

It's time the government expanded its review of 'human error' in relation to apple imports from New Zealand, and cast the net wider to encompass the risk of human mistakes to the entire quarantine system.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Wake up McGauran. As your Government continues to loosen our quarantine arrangements, all in the name of that "holy grail" free trade, we will see ever more episodes like this.

Unfortunately when our agricultural sector gets hit in the guts with an imported disease, like apple blight, it will take more than a few coughs and sneezes to recover.

Lax quarantine at our borders has the potential to destroy much of our disease-free agriculture.

Stop this stupidity before it's too late.

Posted by Agman on 28/08/2007 8:32:57 AM
Why if there is a supposed national lockdown were there horse floats and trucks carrying horses along the Newell Highway, between Narrabri and Moree, all day yesterday (Monday)? Should this not be controlled by someone ?
Posted by Pip on 28/08/2007 3:42:31 PM
In regards to the local Parkes Show being in quarantine - what a load of rot! There were people coming and going, horses walking all over the showground, and they still allowed the Parkes Show Ball to continue on the Saturday night!

It was one of the worst handled situations of quarantine I have ever seen.

And thanks so muck to all those people who went up for a look at the affected horses - patted them through the fence, then walked 100 metres up the road, and patted my horse on the way.

Posted by Kaz on 28/08/2007 5:54:18 PM
Another 'Kerry O'Brien' factual statement that only he, must have access to the correct information, and no one else. How can Howard, McGauran, the National Quarantine system etc possibly be at fault when the 'cause' of entry has not been found. Induendo in a factual statement???
Posted by Billy on 28/08/2007 6:21:32 PM
Regarding the horse at Brookfield near Brisbane that left the infected Warwick site last Saturday, and the debate as to whether it should or should not be tested for EI without first displaying flu-like symptoms, why not in the meantime SHIFT THE THING TO THE NEAREST AVAILABLE QUARANTINE FACILITY !!!
Posted by Common Sense on 28/08/2007 8:13:08 PM
Spot on, Agman!
Posted by Bez on 28/08/2007 8:22:25 PM
Ask the questions louder and longer Senator O'Brien,you are dealing with the same people who stood by and allowed the citrus industry to be decimated/destroyed in Emerald and who want to expose our banana,apple and fishing industry to the same destruction.

Also the racing industry is not the only concern. Warwick is an emotional and financial disaster for all those horses and people, including our Olympic champions, locked down. The greed of the top end of Thoroughbred racing with their Stallion Shuttling system along with the total stupidity of our Quarantine Department has brought this disease into Australia.

Posted by Irish on 29/08/2007 6:36:39 AM
I presume that any metal foundrys in Canberra and Sydney must be running flat out manufacturing cast iron pants for the politicians and senior quarrantine officials to cover their backsides. Don't know how the EI came into the country? What rot! After all this time an efficient quarrantine machine would have been able to demonstrate traceability. FIX OUR QUARRANTINE SYSTEM NOW BEFORE SOMETHING MORE SERIOUS HAPPENS.
Posted by Trugger on 30/08/2007 3:40:44 PM
What all the fuss is about? This is just a horse flu which all the rest of the world survives with no problem.
Posted by andy on 31/08/2007 2:02:20 AM
Why not move the quarantine center back to the island instead of being in Sydney. Maybe the Thoroughbred industry might want to stop calling the shots. I totaly agree with Irish.
Posted by What the! on 3/09/2007 8:31:44 PM
1 | 2 | 3 | 4  |  next >
Lucy Skuthorp is the Rural Press Canberra Bureau chief based in Parliament House.

11/12/2008 | Farm lobby groups will decide next week whether the future of farm representation will stay as it is or be broadened to bring in the big end of town.
FW Subscriptions
 
Freedom Tanks
 
Irwin HunterIrwin Hunter
 
Nextra Inks
 
Rural Bookshop
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...