News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Farm runoff not to blame for coral reef decline 

Farm runoff not to blame for coral reef decline

05 Jan, 2009 06:29 PM
A report that suggests farm runoff cannot be blamed for recent declines in Great Barrier Reef coral health has been paradoxically seized upon by the Queensland Government to justify tough new regulations on farmers.

A study by the Australian Institute of Marine Science (AIMS) has found that a combination of global warming, ocean acidity levels and decreasing carbonate contents in sea water has caused dramatic declines in coral growth rates across the reef in the past 18 years.

While farm run-off is commonly held responsible for declines in reef health, AIMS principal research scientist Dr Katharina Fabrucius told Rural Press this week that farm run-off could not be blamed for the decline.

This was because the decline in coral calcification witnessed during the research had happened in off-shore parts of the reef that could not be reached by farm runoff.

“Farm runoff does not extend to offshore reefs, so we don't believe it is a cause for this decline,” Dr Fabrucius said.

“Instead, the likely causes are interactive effects between warming oceans and ocean acidification, which are both caused by increasing concentrations of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere.”

Despite the clear findings that farming could not be blamed for this decline, Queensland’s minister for Natural Resources Craig Wallace said the study justified the Queensland Government’s plans to regulate farming practices adjacent to the reef.

“We know we'll have opposition out there from industry groups who don't want to see regulation put in place, but this sobering news today from AIMS shows that drastic action must be taken,” he told ABC Radio last Friday.

Mr Wallace’s response has mystified the Canegrowers organisation.

“It is like adding an apple to an orange and getting an elephant,” Canegrowers chief executive officer Ian Ballantyne said.

“There is no logical flow from one to the other as far as I can see.

“If the issue is about emissions management and about global warming, farming operations in Australia account for less than 2pc of all emissions, and within that intensive cropping like sugarcane is a fraction.

“The reality is that regulating or changing the methods or seeking to influence farming methods is not going to impact on the amount of carbon dioxide affecting the reef.”

Mr Ballantyne said the State Government was still not sure how its proposed regulations would work, and was using the AIMS report in an attempt to justify a “political” decision.

The continuous improvement of farming practices and the advent of precision farming, which allowed farmers to apply precisely the amount of chemicals and nutrients they required, had dramatically reduced runoff and the impact of farming activities on the reef in recent years, Mr Ballantyne said.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1


comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
You read all sorts of things in magazines and newspapers, with the qld state government (lower case is deliberate) making such comments. An election is coming on! They need the Green town votes to try and get back into government. So blame the farmers for all sorts of ills, the town-greens are going to love it.
Posted by peter, 6/01/2009 6:45:21 AM
More science proves farmers can't be causing the reef decline. But who cares about science facts because the Qld Labor goverment has a political agenda. They need the Green vote.

Farmers do not blantly destroy the land they live on and get an income from. Education, science, research and financial incentives are the key to improving farm practices - not the big stick of regulation.

Posted by J.L, 6/01/2009 6:48:08 AM
The Minister's (Wallace's) response is not surprising at all. He is, as usual, just pushing the Party line of bush bashing and of course at present probably his chief advisors (who are politicised, in any case) are probably on leave to feed him with a response which might be half logical and sensible.
Posted by Green farmer, 6/01/2009 8:06:39 AM
We are a minority, and seemingly an unnecessary one, given the treatment we receive from the Government. Farmers are to blame for everything. Who will they blame when they have driven us all off the land?
Posted by Helen Clark, 6/01/2009 8:40:01 AM
Does run-off affect near shore reefs? Has run-off any connection with CO2 emissions? Has run-off anything to do with algae bloom? So, is run-off hazard free?
Posted by alice Ekin, 6/01/2009 8:59:00 AM
The so-called decline in the Great Barrier reef is another Furphy put out by the Global Warming alarmists.

A prominent scientist recently reported that if Captain Cook did the same measurements today as he could have done in 1770, there would be no difference on the reefs.

There are about 200 reefs involved and none are in decline. Co2 is not a problem. Getting grant money for eco research is the problem.

Posted by Len, 6/01/2009 12:32:00 PM
You all need to run this politician Craig Wallace out of town - he doesn't understand the issues.
Posted by THE FARMER, 6/01/2009 4:16:45 PM
We all keep repeating what is obvious to us - that Labor and the Greens have no clue and neither do they care what really goes on in the bush.

What is it going to take to get them out of office? Is anyone out there willing to get involved?

If so, email me at "NaturalBeef@aol.com" Maybe together we can do more than just complain to each other.

Posted by Farmer Di, 7/01/2009 8:28:54 AM
If warming is causing the reef to disappear in the north this could be a bonanza for Sydney. Warmer water further south will mean reefs will be able to grow further south. Hooray! Good news!
Posted by Common Cents, 12/01/2009 9:47:18 AM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Most popular articles

Ray White Rural MON0152
 
Irwin HunterIrwin Hunter
 
Small Farms Expo
 
Freedom Tanks
 
IRRIGATION CONFERENCE 2010
 
FBG
 
WA Merino Magazine
 
photo gallery


 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...