News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Farmers join class action on alpine fires 

Farmers join class action on alpine fires

05 Jan, 2009 11:33 PM
The Victorian Government is facing a legal showdown with landowners, farmers and small businesses over the devastating alpine fires of 2003.

A writ lodged on Christmas Eve accuses the State Government, Department of Sustainability and Environment and Parks Victoria of negligence in failing to properly maintain Crown lands and of allowing the fires to escape onto private property.

The writ is the first step in a class action against the Government over its alleged failure to adequately backburn and reduce forest floor litter in state forests, Crown lands and the Alpine National Park ahead of the worst bushfire conditions encountered in decades.

The 2003 inferno began on the night of January 7 when lightning strikes started 80 fires across vast tracts of national park and state forests in north-east Victoria.

The fires converged into the largest bushfire in Victoria since the infamous Black Friday fires of 1939.

They burned for 59 days until March 7 and wiped out more than 1 million hectares of bushland, farms and private property.

Isolated farmhouses, small rural communities and towns such as Omeo spent weeks cloaked in smoke and under threat from the flames.

Operators of the Mount Buffalo Chalet, which was damaged in the fires, are among those preparing to make a claim against the Government.

"It has been coming for a long time," said Simon Paton of the Stretton Group, which has for years lobbied the Government to change its land management practices.

"Beyond the claim for negligence, this goes to a claim for common sense."

Mr Paton is not involved in the legal action.

"Most of these fires were not aggressively attacked when they developed in Crown land and instead became great infernos that raced out of the bush into private property," Mr Paton said.

"Those fires caused all sorts of grief and damage.

There is a problem there and it is big, and if they don't take notice of it now it will come back to haunt us all."

Lodging of the writ follows the findings of a parliamentary inquiry into the impact of public land management practices on bushfires in Victoria.

The inquiry last month called for "a substantial increase in prescribed/ecological burning" on Crown lands.

"The majority of stakeholders argued that the current targeted level of prescribed burning, approximately 130,000 hectares annually, undertaken by DSE and its partner agencies is insufficient to mitigate the impacts of future bushfires and provide the level of fire needed to promote healthy ecological outcomes," the upper house committee noted.

"The committee agrees with these stakeholders and recommends a significant increase in the level of prescribed burning to mitigate the risks associated with future bushfires."

Daniel Oldham, a partner at Slidders Lawyers, which lodged the writ, described the case as being in its infancy but acknowledged that a successful claim against the Government on the 2003 fires could lead to further action.

"We have issued proceedings on behalf of an unspecified number of people, but it is likely to be between 20 and 30 at this stage," he said.

"We expect more over time, as hundreds were affected by these fires."

If a class action proceeds against the State Government over the events of 2003, it is likely others will follow over the 2005 Wilsons Promontory fire, which began as a controlled DSE backburn but escaped.

Action is likely too, over the Grampians and Anakie fires of February, 2006, which burnt more than 100,000 hectares — including 47pc of the Grampians National Park, devastating local tourism.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1



RELATED COVERAGE

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Hopefully this writ will focus the governments attention on the deplorable management of our National Parks. The parks are managed for bush fires and in the arid zones they are managed in such a way that the environment is suffering due to lack of animal and human imputs.

One of the many factors relating to the Vic 2003 fires was the enormous amount of carbon released into the atmosphere. It has been reported that it was three times more than one year's total emmission for the whole of Victoria.

Could Vic Parks be accountable for a percentage of this and have to cough up in dollars to off set their past management system?

It's not as if they have not been told about their inadequate management. For years, the CMA's and farmer organisations' have made sensible, commen sense suggestions in relation to rotational grazing systems to lighten fuel loads and put valuable nutrients back into our soils to increase the function of the landscape to promote a health diverse vegetation.

Also, the animals will greatly reduce the undergrowth. Please, Vic Parks, take this writ as a last ditch effort for sensible, caring farmers who have a pretty good handle on the natural system and put some practical principles in place to manage our fantastic landscape.

Posted by concerned, 5/01/2009 8:17:19 AM
Land managers - on and off farm - have an increasingly difficult task with the 'holocaust' conditions that preceded and endured during the 2003 bushfires.

Important to the debate over the nature of the fires, is the condition of the atmosphere and whether pollution from industry including coal fired power stations in Victoria were precipitants of the dry lightning strikes.

The chemical changes in the atmosphere as a result of pollution including the impact on the intensity, nature and frequency of lightning strikes must be a part of this investigation.

Equally, the existing evidence of the increase in the periodicity of fire and intensity of fire due to suppression of mature forest growth and increase in shrubby undergrowth arising from pastoralism must also be a factor for consideration.

Indigenous fire practices and forest ecology co-evolved. However, European fire practices, including proscribed burns, do not appear to match those historic patterns over tens of thousands of years.

The key factor - failure to recognise the intensity of atmospheric conditions and the need to quickly suppress fire on this occasion - is pivotal to the inquiry.

Posted by Alpine Riverkeeper, 5/01/2009 8:31:12 AM
Perhaps the NSW RFS should now be concerned about possible Class Actions. Remember the fires that burnt Canberra, and the surrounding rural areas?
Posted by Scorched Earth, 5/01/2009 10:13:03 AM
Finally the Victorian Government is being taken to task over it's over-simplistic, ill conceived Green vote grabbing, Crown Land policy of, "lock it up and forget about it."

The 2003 fires were a direct result of the Bracks Governemnt's policies, the infiltration of Parks Victoria and DSE by an extremist Green element, under-resourcing of both departments and the blatant refusal to listen to local communities.

The Country Fire Authority and property owners ajoining Crown Land all had pleaded for the necessary backburning works to be undertaken, but were disdmissed out of hand and their advice and warnings ignored.

Locking up land and failing to maintain it is gross negligence. If private land ownership has fire reduction and clearing obligations, so does Crown Land for Government.

If I failed to maintain my land in Victoria (as the Government does it's Crown Land) I'd be served with clean-up orders by local council and the CFA.

Therefore, if it's good enough for Joe Public, it's good enough for Government, too.

Posted by CQ, 5/01/2009 10:35:00 AM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
A CFA firefighter on the alpine plains in January, 2003. Photo: Simon O'Dwyer
A CFA firefighter on the alpine plains in January, 2003. Photo: Simon O'Dwyer
Related Coverage
ARTICLES

Most popular articles

Ray White Rural MON0152
 
Irwin HunterIrwin Hunter
 
Small Farms Expo
 
Freedom Tanks
 
IRRIGATION CONFERENCE 2010
 
FBG
 
WA Merino Magazine
 
photo gallery


 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...