News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Horse owners to be hit by levy 

Horse owners to be hit by levy

2/09/2008 4:21:00 PM
Federal Member for Maranoa, Bruce Scott will tonight oppose the Rudd Government’s legislation to enforce a horse disease response levy on Australia’s equine industry.

Mr Scott said the levy, which would be activated in the event of another equine disease outbreak, such as the equine influenza and Hendra virus, would be imposed upon all registered horses, regardless of the risk they posed to Australia’s biosecurity.

“With 80pc of registered horses used for pleasure activities, the burden of this ill-conceived levy will fall on the industry’s recreational sector, despite it being highly unlikely it would be responsible for the introduction of a foreign disease,” Mr Scott said.

“The outbreak of equine influenza last year had a financially devastating impact across all sectors of the horse industry – racehorse owners, jockeys, equine-related small businesses, vets, horse breeders, camp drafters and pony club families were all affected by the virus.

“Should another outbreak of an equine disease occur, imposing such a levy would only further hurt an industry facing financial hardship.

“The Rudd Government should not be focused on recouping costs from a possible future outbreak, but instead should be dedicated to immediately improving our quarantine measures to ensure it does not happen again,” he said.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size


Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
JUST ANOTHER WAY FOR THE GOVERMENT TO RE-COUP FOR THEIR OWN MISTAKE. AND YES ALSO TO HAVE TOTAL DOCUMENTED CONTROL OF ALL HORSE OWNERS. JUST ANOTHER TAX.
Posted by Shayno on 2/09/2008 9:02:53 PM
This is so typical of this government. So does this mean that other livestock owners will be subject to a levy as well if, say, foot and mouth is imported. The disease outbreak has nothing to do with the animal owner, the source would be traced back to poor quarantine/customs inspections and tests, as was in the EI outbreak. In NSW with the proposed horse registration with the amalgamation of RLPB's, will the levy be exempt in NSW? Will the National Park Service pay a levy on the brumbies? This whole scheme is nothing more than buck passing so that, as with the current KRudd government policy, everyone else is to blame, but not the government.
Posted by jerangle on 3/09/2008 6:45:46 AM
Should not happen as there are too many voters who own horses. Also it is clear that the bright spark who came up with this idea knows nothing about the horse industry what so ever.
Posted by martia on 3/09/2008 6:58:35 AM
"despite it being highly unlikely it would be responsible for the introduction of a foreign disease" ... So who should suffer the burden of another broad based tax imposed by government as a cure all so the sections of the industry that can most afford to pay is subsidised by the rest. Answer: well all horses look the same.

A cynic would say those who vote and pass legislation are also seen around the tracks or in the betting facilities, or is the ownership of horses seen as one of privilege?

If horses are an industry and that industry import or transports a comodity (horses) to or from destinations which pose a risk to that industry and its subsidiaries then the importer should pay and better manage their QA and quarantine practices; "naw" that wouldn't raise enough revenue!

Posted by Realist on 3/09/2008 7:19:24 AM
Do they think the government will bail them out again if the can't foot part of the bill? The government paid about $110m just to mount the response, and I would wager they won't do it again if the industry doesn't help itself. Better off killing the levy and keeping your head in the sand eh?
Posted by Horse on 3/09/2008 7:25:20 AM
If the government was filled with educated and knowledgeable people and actually provided effective quarantine, then the issue would not arrive. Taxes could then be spent effectively with less administration chewing up available dollars. Hopefully levies won't appear to cater for these unknowns caused through mismanagement on all fronts
Posted by frustrated on 3/09/2008 9:07:54 AM
If the horse industry, in all its facets and levels of investment, cannot start to work together as a responsible entity, it cannot expect anyone, governments included, to take it seriously. A responsible levy system for the horse industry has been attempted for many years with sadly ignorant and emotional arguments impeding any progress. Horse owners will be the ultimate losers. I am disappointed that Bruce Scott has not thought more thoroughly about what he is opposing.
Posted by sugna on 3/09/2008 9:16:50 AM
The horse industry is the ONLY industry not to have these levy arrangements in place. They are also the only industry allowed to import live animals into Australia, and the only industry not to have to keep livestock waybills or comply with NLIS. To answer Jarengle's question, yes, other livestock industries WOULD help pay if Foot and Mouth broke in this country: the cost sharing and levy arrangements have been in place for years. And if Foot and Mouth got in it would likely not be the fault of ANY livestock sector but of some silly tourist. It's about time the horse industry decided if it is a leisure sport or actually an industry which contributes to this economy. You can't have it both ways - didn't segments of the "recreational" horse sector also qualify for hardship relief during the EI outbreak? How does that work if it is purely recreational?
Posted by Horse Owning vet on 3/09/2008 10:20:49 AM
I believe that a bond should be put up by the multi million dollar syndicates who move the shuttle stallions around the world as they are the group responsible for the last fiasco that crippled the non racing equine industry.
Posted by worried on 3/09/2008 10:28:46 AM
Another blame game... The government have ignored peoples warnings of lax quarantine, for far too long...This bit of saying you will have to pay, is just KRudd, the government already collect a lot of tax and not controlling our borders is the blame of the government, if it was people paddling boats in, they would be quarantining them correctly, but no its a horse so blame the horse owner... Lets face it, the government need to start looking at ways to improve on a system that failed, end of story...They don't need to work how to pay the money back, we already paid once, by tax, why pay again...oh yeh blame one group and gain more votes from another.
Posted by wraithe on 3/09/2008 2:08:25 PM
1 | 2  |  next >

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

11/12/2008 | Farm lobby groups will decide next week whether the future of farm representation will stay as it is or be broadened to bring in the big end of town.
FW Subscriptions
 
Nextra Inks
 
Freedom Tanks
 
Irwin HunterIrwin Hunter
 
Rural Bookshop
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...