News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Readers react strongly to $303m Twynam water sale 

Readers react strongly to $303m Twynam water sale

31 May, 2009 01:13 PM
STRONG readers' comments on FarmOnline have been posted following the government's purchase of almost 240 gigalitres of water entitlements for $303 million from the Twynam Agricultural Group.

For instance, 'tax payer', has responded to the story: 'Feds buy $303m of Twynam water', saying:

"After all the money that has been thrown around to try and stimulate the economy, this money has been spent to kill a huge part of the economy permanently.

"Businesses like mine rely on businesses like Twynam spending a few bob on machinery every few years. We can put up with temporary droughts but permanent decisions by naive and illinformed politicians will have a lasting effect.

"Nation building infrastructure and projects that have secured wealth for regional Australia have just been given away.

"To all of our ancestors who busted their guts to develop this great land we are sorry that we have given in to the foolishness of this current government.

"To the future generations who will have to make a life in another region of Australia or overseas we are sorry.

"To our agricultural competitors in other lands, we have shot ourselves in the foot once again."

But most readers don't blame the Twynam Group itself, rather they blame government policy for spending this money on buying water instead of re-building the Murray-Darling irrigation infrastructure first, to improve efficiency and so save even more water.

For instance, Jimim says:

"Don't blame Twynam for making a commercial decision that is available to them.

"Blame the total rural community for not getting together and causing enough trouble for the government to have to take notice."

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
I think we farmers should all take heed of Twynam ...anyone that is serious about owning land and being in agriculture as a professional business in Australia should seriously think about shifting your core asset to an agriculture-friendly country ... because there is no future here. I think Twynam should be commended for their great business sense; the simple fact is the average Australian just doesn't want farmers or ag at all and they want the Government to thieve and steal all our land and assets in the name of conservation. Most farmers I know just want the Govt to buy all their land at market value, and then we would leave this giant national park to the Wongs and Garretts, like Twynam.
Posted by The Serf, 31/05/2009 4:51:29 PM
Typical labor gov'ment ripping the heart of the aussie farming apart. Shame on the gov,ment, shame on you kahlbetzer family for giving in to the money grabbing. Rural jobs and keeping farms viable without water??? Wake up to yourselves. Why do we want the greenies running our country? Let the farmers run our country for a while, at least we can stand the pressures droughts and floods.
Posted by roger, 1/06/2009 4:35:16 AM
Where is the KRudd government taking rural folk? The government has reduced rural funding by millions, then announce a sizeable handout to agricultural projects in developing countries, while our research and development suffers when most needed. Is buying water for environmental projects far more important than growing food for our own people, I think not! Hasn't Penny Wong realised yet, that water entitlements without water, aren't much use. God only knows what will become of farmers when she eventually introduces the carbon tax. Maybe the Prime Minister should forget trying for his seat on the UN and prepare his seat in the class room instead, ready for teaching us all Mandarin, so in future we will understand the language required, when buying our fruit and veg at the supermarket.
Posted by Martin, 1/06/2009 7:07:01 AM
Bit harsh Roger. The Kahlbetzer's have sold the allocation water which doesn't exist because it hasn't rained. Shame on the government I agree for wasting our money. Now is the time for all farmers to stand together. Pay your memberships to your lobby organisations even if you don't attend the meetings and take an active role. We need to support those who are willing to give their time and energy to fight for the right of agriculture. Now is not the time to throw rocks and whinge and say how it used to be. Now is the time for some serious lobbying. There are channels to influence governemnt so now is the time to fill those channels. Let's pull together and demonstrate to the people of this country we are the backbone and the hand that feeds them, so back off and be grateful you have fresh safe produce on the shelves. Be happy you live in a country where the environment is given consideration by the industries that use it. These are tough times for everyone but rest assured the population of Australia will not go cold or hungry while ever we have farmers to put food on the table. This government needs a serious wake up call and it needs to be supported by all in agriculture. Our livlehoods are threatened so let's put our differences aside and save our industry.
Posted by Sam, 1/06/2009 7:10:25 AM
Oh please wake up, the ag sector is never going to win if it goes toe to toe with the urban greenies. You cannot have an ag sector without the environment sector. It is time to show the urban greenines that farmers do care about the envioronment and will look after it better than they can. The flow of energy through the environmental systems is what supports farming, the bloody minded Us and Them attitude is doing more harm than good. The urban greenies are quite right in trying to protect THEIR country too, they are Australian and you do not own rural Australia. This is Australia and every Australian owns it and has a right to see how it is governed, this is democracy and the rural landholders are only a small part of the electorate and most urban greenies I speak to see farmers as whinging environmental rapists (I do not agree but that is thier view) without the IQ to do anything but mine the land. The worst thing is that the farmers fall for the political rubbish spewed out by thier leaders and think that they are doing them a favour by standing up for them when in the democratic process you will be crushed. Do you really think Barnaby Joyce even gets a look in when people are voting, he is just seen as a crazy red neck trying to protect his own interests at the expense of the Australian environment, he is doing landholders more harm than good, he is the dingo in the tent!
Posted by the lorax, 1/06/2009 9:59:38 AM
Reading the first comment prompts me to ask what is 'The Serf' going to do about this situation? The answer - start by reading 'Sam's comments!
Posted by BJF, 1/06/2009 10:03:36 AM
To remain sustainable in agriculture today, hard decisions need to be made. All Twynam have done is sell something thay haven't had for years, but have been paying huge sums of money for anyway. Unfortunately for the environment & the taxpayer, what the government has puchased is not yet there & may not be there for a long time to come. Twynam farms have not become national parks, but will now hopefully become more sustainable into the future, to help keep local people employed & local businesses viable, because they have now relieved themselves of huge yearly costs, before a crop is even in the ground. If the State Government relieved irrigators of the huge costs of paying year after year for something they haven't been getting, the story may have had a different ending.
Posted by WIL, 1/06/2009 1:02:22 PM
No “BJF”, perhaps not reading “Sam’s” comments is the first thing the “The Serf” is going to do. The first thing “The Serf” is probably going to do is what the owners of Twynam are doing. It’s called “Moving”. After years of Government appeasement, It now appears too late for any State Farming Organisation to have any useful role to play, other than to sit back and watch the final nails being hammered into Australian agriculture.
Posted by Dr Bob, 1/06/2009 5:52:48 PM
This Twynam purchase is the best thing to happen for us people lower down the river system. What is all the bitching about? It is obvious to anyone with half a brain that there is not enough water to go around in the Murray-Darling. Someone has to stop using the water, and Twynam have put their hand up. If it wasn't for the Federal Government buyback there would be enterprises going bust all over the place, with no compensation. And Twynam are not giving up, just re-financing themselves into a more sensible mode of farming under the present circumstances.
Posted by Barney, 2/06/2009 12:35:53 PM
It's time for change. I know it seems awful at the moment, with "greenies" calling for extreme measures, and certain sectors of the farming community wanting things to continue just as they are. But as I've learnt over time, compromise and careful forward thinking and planning can make all the difference.

There are ways for greenies to acheive great results for the environment while at the same time farmers can acheive great results from the land.

I saw an eye opening and inspirational person on Australian Story the other night (check out their website to watch the program that I saw), Dr Maarten Stapper. People like this can change the way "greenies" and farmers come together.

It's in all of our interests to change the way things are currently being done. It's not working...I would like my children to be able to have local, sustainably produced food on their tables when they are adults.

Come on "greenies", come on farmers, let's do it...

Posted by I Love Farmers, 4/06/2009 8:51:03 AM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
DOCUMENTS
MULTIMEDIA
29 May, 2009
POLL
Q: Do you believe human activity is the cause of climate change?

Yes
(43.6%)

No
(48%)

Undecided
(8.4%)

Total Votes: 1138
Poll Date: 24 May, 2009

Most popular articles

Advertisement

Irwin Hunter 160x160


Farm Weekly







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...