News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Whales give carbon emissions a bum steer 

Whales give carbon emissions a bum steer

17 Jun, 2010 04:36 AM
SPERM whales in the Southern Ocean are doing their bit for the battle against global warming.

The giant mammals help remove about 400,000 tonnes of carbon from the atmosphere a year by releasing large quantities of liquid faeces into the upper layers of the ocean, Australian researchers have calculated.

Trish Lavery, of Flinders University, said whale poo is rich in iron and stimulates the growth of phytoplankton - microscopic plants that soak up carbon dioxide. ''When the phytoplankton die, the trapped carbon sinks to the deep ocean.''

Ms Lavery and her team have estimated that industrial culling of sperm whales has resulted in an extra 2 million tonnes of carbon dioxide a year remaining in the atmosphere. ''It makes a compelling case for an immediate ban on whaling,'' she said.

Whales had previously been accused of having a large carbon footprint because they exhale a lot of carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas. But the study shows they more than offset these emissions by defecating.

Sperm whales, of which there are an estimated 12,000 in the Southern Ocean, dive deep to consume a diet of squid and fish.

The researchers calculated they release about 50 tonnes of iron near the surface in their faeces, which floats around and fertilises the iron-poor waters, increasing phytoplankton blooms.

Although whales exhale about 200,000 tonnes of carbon a year, the net gain is 200,000 tonnes of carbon locked in the ocean for hundreds or thousands of years.

The sperm whales in the Southern Ocean represent only about three per cent of the global population, and those elsewhere could also make a significant contribution to carbon removal from the atmosphere, the researchers said.

So could other kinds of whales and sea creatures that feed deep in the ocean and poo in the surface layers where light is available for photosynthesis.

''Seals and sealions often consume prey at depth, but whether the waste is liquid and buoyant requires further investigation,'' the researchers said.

Before whaling began there used to be about 10 times as many sperm whales in the Southern Ocean.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Warning, warning, Whale$hit Alert! The only whales being hunted are Minke's, not Sperm Whales, and there is between 600,000 to 1,000,000 of them. And 50 tonnes of Iron divided by 12,000 whales averages out at only 4KG per animal. The price of iron ore is about $200/tonne (20 cents/KG) so each whale only delivers 80 cents worth of iron to the oceans each year. That makes only $10,000 worth for the entire species. In fact, a single Hamersley rail wagon carries more iron in one trip than the entire species delivers in a year. The dust and fines from a single 3000 tonne train load would be more than these animals deliver in a year and it currently is not even costed. So clearly, if the greens were serious about absorbing CO2, and the conversion rate of iron through phytoplankton to absorbed CO2 is correct, then they need only vacuum up 50 tonnes of free iron ore dust from the Hamersley each year, rent a decent lobster boat in the off-season, and do the same job as 12,000 whales in a single trip,
Posted by Ian Mott, 18/06/2010 7:32:09 AM
Had an interesting case put to me that puts whaling in another light. As Ian has said there are around a 600000-1000000 Minkes. Their net number increase by 5% per year (allowing for births and deaths), so there is another 30-50000 Minkes each years. From memory, there is about 1500 Minkes hunted each year, so thats represent less than 5% of the population increase. Is this not sustainable? I, like most have ethical issues with whaling, but the above analysis does give it some balance. Perhaps there is a sustainable industry available if it is managed correctly?
Posted by The orchardist, 18/06/2010 9:16:17 AM
Of course there is a sustainable industry potential in whaling, Orchardist. The secret to sustainable harvesting of any herd is to first protect the young, then identify, and then cull, the surplus males and post-breeding females so theremaining herd have improved access to their food resources. In a beef cattle herd this allows the annual cull of about one third of the total herd. The breeding rate of whales is not as frequent but some quality research without the green ideological blinkers could soon identify the basic parameters and associated technical requirements. Indeed, it is quite clear that the whale wonkers haven't given the slightest thought to how they will deal with the pending ecological disequilibrium that will be produced when whale-kind continues growing beyond their natural balance. But this is nothing new, they do this with all species. They all agree that Polar Bears, for example, have grown in numbers from a low of 5,000 animals 50 years ago to more than 25,000 today but are now blaming the resulting declines in average body weight on global warming, not the five fold increase in predators of a static seal population. They just don't get the basic ecology.
Posted by Ian Mott, 18/06/2010 2:05:09 PM
Whales - the beef of the sea - thanks Gruen Transfer
Posted by The Lorax, 21/06/2010 7:28:36 AM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
MULTIMEDIA
16 June, 2010
POLL
Q: Who is your preferred Prime Minister?

Kevin Rudd
(8.4%)

Tony Abbott
(55.5%)

Julia Gillard
(7.3%)

Malcolm Turnbull
(17.3%)

Other
(11.5%)

Total Votes: 1329
Poll Date: 13 June, 2010

Most popular articles


Irwin Hunter 160x160


Farm Weekly







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...