News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Will a full Lake Eyre bring rain to southern Aus? 

Will a full Lake Eyre bring rain to southern Aus?

22 Jan, 2009 02:42 PM
The continued big wet over western Queensland and the Northern Territory is not only raising prospects of a boom season through the Channel Country, it also is likely to mean the best run of water into Lake Eyre for at least five years.

There have been heavy falls across parts of western Queensland that have resulted in floods in places such as Mount Isa, Cloncurry and Birdsville, which are feeding key Lake Eyre catchments such as the Diamantina River and Georgina Creek.

Further rainfall of up to 70mm to Tuesday in the Queensland catchment and the forecast of further rain this week has BOM hydrologists expecting the best inflows since at least 2004.

However, a Bureau of Meteorology spokesperson has stressed that the volume water actually which ends up in Australia's largest lake is largely dependent on weather conditions through the catchment from now on.

In terms of where the water will come from, flooding has been heaviest on the Georgina River and the Eyre Creek catchment, where the Bureau spokesman said flows were the heaviest for 10 years.

There has been a major flood warning for the Georgina River catchment for much of the week, including warnings for places such as Bedourie, Camoweal and Urandangie, following flooding earlier in January.

But flows from Lake Eyre's other major feeder, Cooper Creek, are small at this stage.

While it is agreed both by the BOM and other Lake Eyre monitors, such as the Lake Eyre Yacht Club, which keeps an eye on the lake with a view to sailing there should there be sufficient water, that there will be water in the lake at some point, it is unknown how much water will make the lake or when.

"It is likely that water will arrive until early to mid February, but as the water is not even in South Australia yet it is difficult to say how much or when," the Bureau spokesman said.

Along with pleasing South Australian and Queensland graziers, the news has also caught the eye of croppers in eastern and south-eastern Australia, many of whom believe that a full Lake Eyre is a signal of a good rainfall the following winter.

One of the ideas behind this is that the evaporation off the Lake is caught by passing cold fronts and creates greater rainfall in the south-east.

The theory is so prevalent that some farmers believe the government should pump sea water from the Spencer Gulf's most northern point across to Lake Torrens and Lake Eyre to generate more reliable rainfall for south-eastern Australia.

However, the BOM was quick to pour cold water on the theory.

"The perception of a relationship between Lake Eyre filling and a wet winter the next year is there, but the research has showed there is not much correlation," said BOM climatologist Blair Trewin.

He said one reason the theory existed was that Lake Eyre was often filled by a La Nina summer, which could then be followed by a La Nina winter, also associated with higher than average eastern seaboard rainfall.

"The evaporation theory could be explained as somewhat of a red herring," he said.

BOM research scientist Pandora Hope has done work specifically on Lake Eyre's effect on eastern Australian rainfall and said there was no specific reason water in Lake Eyre could influence weather patterns elsewhere.

"We have done some modelling, taking out the effect of a La Nina, to see what impact evaporation has on rainfall patterns, and it does not lead to greater rainfall," she said.

"The evaporation does lead to localised cooling and higher humidity, but this is only in the immediate area, basically above the Lake's surface.

"One of the main problems is that Lake Eyre generally sits under a high pressure system and the lows would not be near enough to harvest the moisture."

One farmer who refuses to be deterred by this explanation is Murtoa's Dale Frankel, who this year publicly called for the filling of Lake Torrens and Lake Eyre.

"There's certainly anecdotal evidence to support it, and I believe that if the two lakes are filled over our key growing season months of autumn, winter and spring, then we'd see higher rainfall as a result," he said.

"You see where most of the world's wettest places are – near the coast, where cold fronts feed off evaporation, so there's no reason it should not apply to eastern and south-eastern Australia.

"The cost of engineering such a project, which would only require a small amount of pumping the water from Port Augusta before it would gravity feed down into the lake system, pales into insignificance compared with all the feasibility studies and buyback schemes for the Murray-Darling that the federal government is spending money on at the moment.

"I'm not saying all the evaporation would be transformed into rainfall for south-eastern Australia, but I think it is a project the government should look more seriously at."

As for environmental concerns, he said that much of the area where a channel would run was already saline so it would not be an issue.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Interesting theory. But it's already been tested with an existing body of water further west. It's called the Indian Ocean. The Gibson, Great Sandy, Tanami, Victoria, Simpson, Strzelecki and Sturts Stony deserts are just that, though. Deserts. Not salad bowls.

Governments are quite capable of wasting money on their own without encouragement from people that rely on "anecdotal" evidence.

Posted by Brindi, 22/01/2009 6:15:45 PM
Perhaps even with some proper planning hydro electricity could be designed into the project and because maximum evaporation would be in the summer months when electricity usage peaks could add to the projects benefits. It is about time more construction of vital infrastructure was done in this country.
Posted by Ray, 23/01/2009 5:51:38 AM
In 1974 an experienced veterinarian advising a major pastoral company observed that Lake Eyre was full. At a conference in Wagga he predicted 5 good years of rainfall would follow. He was right. Chance or not? Does anyone have facts on when Lake Eyre has been filled and what rainfall has followed in Eastern states?
Posted by Common Cents, 23/01/2009 6:48:25 AM
A lot of Australia was covered in rainforest and mega fauna not to mention millions of visiting flamingos and other waterbirds when the centre of Australia was a small sea. I say get some of the big gear sitting around idle at minesites and dig a big trench/ tunnel where applicable down from NT and up from South Oz to fill the low ground in the middle again.

Not only will you have an amazing opportunity to farm salt water species, but I reckon Australia will enjoy very high rainfall again because of it.

All that ancient soil in the centre only needs rain water to flourish. Plus the tidal flow can run hydro-electirc or tidal power generation plants on the way.

Let's think (real) big plans and long term.

Damming up more coastal rivers is not the solution and all the pros reckon it is going to get a lot drier with the current set up- so let's move and make it happen.

Posted by Big Diggers and Dozers- lots of em, 23/01/2009 7:57:16 AM
Love that "out there" thinking above BUT reality is that any project is a huge exercise (HUGE) but why not think up everything imaginable to come up with those that may be possible - what about a huge open waterway from NT to SA with osmosis stations along it (that run off solar energy) to desalinate - the waterway could run from the top end where tropical rain occurs - down to the centre of Australia & Southern areas - The water would be fresh by the time it gets to the centre areas, fresh enough to store & treat as we do in cities anyway & create the ability to poulate these areas - population away from the coastal areas could be beneficial as the seaboard areas begin to overpopulate (the balance between population & infrastructure is delicete one anywhere) in this waterway, evaporation could be reduced with the doubling of services as such as transport roads, bridges & tunnels on the same corridor and having it big enough that container vessels could use it - crazy ideas I know - there were ideas decades ago about satellite cities designed & developed in these remote areas, (does anyone reading know about them?) - these days we can look to the middle east places where they are doing amazing things with creating sustainablity in desert areas (thay must begin as crazy ideas!) - If we could afford to harness water & create transport out there, this could also help to respond to Chinese & other imports as there could be manufacturing industries grown with the right transport wich could become more viable than from overseas as the cost of that will now start to rise as the world deals with rising costs too ...
Posted by think differently & catch good ideas !, 26/01/2009 10:23:42 AM
Lake Eyre has been full before. I don't recall it making much difference then. Check back on the statistics.
Posted by Ted O'Brien, 2/02/2009 2:32:00 PM
I think it's a great idea. Right now, nothing but 50 degree heat comes from there - and yet once it was a lake.
Posted by louis, 10/02/2009 5:23:24 PM
Yes!!! Having flown over a full lake Eyre I totally agree. It would be a magnificent forward thinking project that would serve our country well into the future and support the many millions of families that Australia will need to support in years to come. Australia could lead the world in forward thinking - it would be a massive enviromental restorative project. We had it once ...let's bring it back to life. Can we do it ? - YES we can!!!
Posted by Bargara, 15/02/2009 11:50:35 AM
I think it is a great idea. Westerly winds would drive the humid air onto the western slopes of the Great Dividing Range, causing increased rainfall into southern Australia, something that cannot happen in the south from the Indian Ocean, as it's mostly just flat country that the air moves over. All for it.
Posted by johnc6, 25/02/2009 2:21:08 PM
B.H.P want to build a desalination plant at Whyalla. Why not get them to build it next to Lake Eyre, and let them put a channel in place and let the water flow up there? Why have the on-going expense of pumping water thousands of kilometres? They have open cut machines that remove 25 tons of dirt at a time. It would not take that long to put in place. The saline water and other seawater you pump back into Lake Torrens and when it dries out you export the salt. This creates exports and jobs. In Mr Peter Andrews book he says that the years in the fifties and early sixties were wet in the southern states. The Lake was filled in 1955. A large lake of water would moderate extremes of weather. The fires in Victoria were caused by hot thermal air drying out the forests and then in hot windy weather they all exploded in flames. That hot air came from the middle of Australia. If the lake was filled with water then you have a large moist air in the middle of Australia, you reduce the risks of extreme weather conditions. Having the lake filled would draw moisture further inland. Mr Andrews said in his book that when they built a large dam in NSW the rain fall increased in that part of the state by about 10 inches per year. If the lake was filled and there was a 10 inch increase in rain fall in the southern states with fewer droughts, then wheat farmers would receive huge benefits. If they grew different types of wheat based on greater average rainfall I am sure that they would not mind. It also could lead to better farming practice as the round up could be put back on the shelf.
Posted by Paul, 16/04/2009 8:46:52 PM
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
The floods in North Queensland will deliver the best flow into Lake Eyre in years.
The floods in North Queensland will deliver the best flow into Lake Eyre in years.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
MULTIMEDIA
13 January, 2009
POLL
Q: Should Nationals Senator Barnaby Joyce try a move to the House of Representatives at the next Federal election?

Yes
(51.8%)

No
(42.1%)

Other
(6.1%)

Total Votes: 444
Poll Date: 18 January, 2009

Most popular articles

ELDERS NEWS MREC FW

Irwin Hunter 160x160
 
Banjawarn Station


Farm Weekly







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...