News 
 National Rural News 
 Grains and Cropping 
 General 
 Single desk activists stage protest 

Single desk activists stage protest

30 Dec, 2009 06:33 AM
THERE was a noisy protest at last week’s AWB annual general meeting (AGM) from a group of growers dedicated to re-establishing the single desk marketing system.

Growers from central and southern NSW carried around a mock coffin, while leading single desk campaigner Jock Munro, replete with kilt, played a dirge on the bagpipes on busy LaTrobe Street, Melbourne, in front of AWB’s Ceres House headquarters prior to the AGM.

The protest was not limited to before the meeting, with AWB chairman Peter Polson forced to answer several questions on AWB’s role in the dismantling of the single desk.

“It was not AWB that got rid of the single desk,” he said.

However, Pat Drum, Balldale, NSW, questioned whether AWB had been lobbying to have the wheat marketing system opened up.

“I have sources in Canberra and they said you were there right through the decision making period, lobbying to have the single desk dismantled.”

Mr Munro said AWB’s actions during the period of marketing reform were ‘shameful’.

“You’ve helped destroy the single desk, and you’ve helped to destroy the company that was established by our fathers and grandfathers.

“You demeaned the grower directors as not being up to the job, and look what has happened now, a $200 million loss.”

Mark Dwyer, Rankins Springs, NSW, said he was unhappy the company’s poor showing had eroded the value of shares he was forced to take out through the former Wheat Industry Fund.

“I made compulsory contributions of $50,000 to this company through the WIF, and now shares have dropped to $1.07, so I feel as though you owe me some money.”

A testy Mr Polson, clearly agitated by over two and a half hours of statements masquerading as questions to him, said debate on the wheat marketing act was not AWB’s concern, as a listed company dedicated to maximising shareholder returns.

“The world has moved on and AWB is a different entity to then.

“The board understands the value of its customers, and we don’t believe we have abandoned growers, but equally we understand that there will enmity towards this company so long as Mr Munro lives.

“All I can say is that we didn’t do away with the single desk, and you can drag coffins and play bagpipes but AWB can’t re-establish it.

“These protests are becoming pure theatre, and while they may help Mr Munro exorcise his demons, we have to focus on our competition, big competition in maintaining our share of the wheat market.”

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
If that is the single desk in the coffin, it must be unbearably smelly, given the poor old thing died about 18 months ago. I think old Jock et al have been taking lessons from old Barnaby on self-generated and self-serving publicity stunts. As with Barnaby's self-promotion gimmicks, Jock's efforts are laughable. Get over it, and get on with life in the new world.
Posted by Bushie Bill, 30/12/2009 10:38:14 AM
There is really only two ways a listed company like AWB can generate a profit for its shareholders and that is to buy as cheap as possible from the growers and sell as dear as possible which isn't really much of an option in a global market, or to over-service or overcharge its growers and service providers
Posted by Will, 30/12/2009 10:53:47 AM
Bushie Bill, Jock and his supporters are not exhibitionists. They are realists who will not let this thing die, because they know that to reintroduce some grower equity into the market place growers and the decision makers must be constantly reminded of what was lost in a brazen act of corporate and political treachery.
Posted by Full Profile., 31/12/2009 5:00:35 AM
Stop embarassing yourselves, boys. This is simply what you asked for: lower prices because you sold us out. It's done and we have to cop it. You didn't mind taking all the free dinners & parties when you were there & should have been working for those who funded you - so stop complaining and whining. As ye sow, so shall ye reap.....
Posted by Oh please!, 31/12/2009 5:24:52 AM
I have just seen a photograph from another article on this ratbaggery, and noticed these clowns are not only stupid, they can’t spell. The very least they should do is to use correctly spelt English on the coffin, the focus of their publicity stunt. They display their ignorance and arrogance for all to see.
Posted by Bushie Bill, 31/12/2009 5:53:39 AM
To Bushie Bill et al. I think you may be the ignorant one. Since AWB Ltd conned A class shareholders into "normalising" the company, this board have lost hundreds of millions in a dodgy trading office in Brazil, Gordon davis's brainchild I'm told, and in an attempt to dig themselves out of that mess they have diss-enfranchised the retail shareholders (mostly Growers) in a very poorly run share issue that has left these retail shareholders with less than 38% of the shares. These people are supposed to be professionals, but at what is anyones guess. Since the loss of the Single Desk Growers have not only lost the company that was built with levied capital but any equity in their own industry, traders dictate the terms now and the industry is paying for it with lost markets, no quality assurance and chaotic transport and handling logistics. You are obviously not a Grower or you would be aware of these issues, if you are a grower you should probably have a closer look at what is going on around you
Posted by mark2, 31/12/2009 10:56:52 AM
Yes Mark, you are right they are not grain growers because they also would be feeling the pain. Could you fellows please explain, get over it and move on with your life means... move onto what?
Posted by Pedro, 31/12/2009 11:30:09 AM
Bushie Bill, You might find the whole thing laughable but if it was such a joke why have Jock and his mates been taken seriously by the elite Media of this Nation? The treacherous removal of the tried and proven Wheat Single Desk will in time become a National shame and embarassment.
Posted by Full Profile., 31/12/2009 3:48:08 PM
Pedro, you can accept change, and the challenges it presents, or you can move on to something else. Is that not what everyone does in determining how to make a living? Sitting in the corner whinging about the good old days and expecting to reverse history does exactly nothing in producing a viable business. No one is holding a gun at your head, forcing you to continue growing wheat. If you cannot or will not accept the challenges of change, what other option do you have? Why are wheat farmers any different to other economic sectors? If a small supermarket owner or a butcher or a baker finds a Colesworth opening 200 metres away, who protects them? They are on their own, and they get on with their lives the best way they can, without expecting others to solve their problems. Why shouldn’t you do the same? Full Profile, you are a funny, and it is hilarious reading “Jock and his supporters are not exhibitionists. They are realists who will not let this thing die”. I have some news for you, and for Jock and his merry men-the single desk is dead, very dead, so dead that even these deadheads are carrying it around in a coffin. They should all go home, nobody is listening.
Posted by Bushie Bill, 31/12/2009 4:17:53 PM
You've done it again, Full Profile. You are so funny. If you think these clowns are being taken seriously by the elite media of the nation, you are out of your tree. Hint: the media is laughing at them. Even the rural media is laughing at them. They can't even spell "losing", which is ironic, given that they are such losers themselves.
Posted by Bushie Bill, 1/01/2010 1:17:51 PM
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Nail in the coffin: Jock Munro, Rankins Springs, on bagpipes mourns the death of the single desk with pallbearers Pat Drum, Balldale, Geoff McLellan, Rand, Rod Hatty, Ardlethan and Mark Dwyer, Rankins Springs (obscured) at the AWB AGM.
Nail in the coffin: Jock Munro, Rankins Springs, on bagpipes mourns the death of the single desk with pallbearers Pat Drum, Balldale, Geoff McLellan, Rand, Rod Hatty, Ardlethan and Mark Dwyer, Rankins Springs (obscured) at the AWB AGM.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
MULTIMEDIA
21 December, 2009
18 December, 2009
POLL
Q: Did the Copenhagen summit strengthen or weaken the case for an ETS?

Strengthened
(3.7%)

Weakened
(29.7%)

About the same
(5.8%)

We never needed an ETS
(60.8%)

Total Votes: 775
Poll Date: 24 December, 2009

Most popular articles


Irwin Hunter 160x160


Farm Weekly







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...