News 
 National Rural News 
 Wool 
 General 
 Non-mulesed wool contracts to go overseas 

Non-mulesed wool contracts to go overseas

18 Jun, 2009 06:49 AM
WOOL leaders have warned that a surge in international apparel brands turning their back on wool from mulesed Merino sheep is taking shape, in a move that could see Australia lose valuable market share to its competitors.

At the same time as Marks and Spencer's head of technology, Krishan Hundal, declared publicly the company's decision to source only wool form non-mulesed sheep for its menswear business, one of its Australian supply chain partners has signaled that this is just the start of a building world-wide movement.

The Merino Company's (TMC) chief executive, Mark Mackinnon, said Marks and Spencer's announcement last Wednesday to cease buying wool from mulesed sheep for its menswear business by the end of 2010 was simply the retail giant holding firm to a commitment it flagged five years ago and came as "no surprise".

"They are sticking to their policy," Mr MacKinnon said.

"Certainly some others (retail outlets) are starting to move and I am almost certain there will be more."

Marks and Spencer source up to 80,000 bales of Merino wool annually, of which around 30-40 per cent is used in menswear.

Marks and Spencer is amongst 10 global retail companies, including Nike, Gap, Hugo Boss, Abercrombie and Fitch, Timberland, H&M, American Eagle, Columbia Sports Wear and Liz Claiborne that have announced publicly their opposition to mulesing in recent years.

Mr Mackinnon said TMC would have "absolutely no problem" supplying its largest client with its non-mulesed wool demands.

But asked if orders could be filled using exclusively Australian non-mulesed Merino wool and Mr Mackinnon said "probably not".

"Around 20per cent of the apparel wool is from unmulesed sheep, of which Australia has a small portion – this is the issue," he said.

"Australia used to achieve a premium over all other markets and that premium has now gone."

Mr Mackinnon said South Africa and South America (where mulesing is not done) had caught up in the wool quality stakes and to meet orders TMC would look there.

"The million dollar question is how many Marks and Spencer's have to come on board before supply becomes an issue?" he said.

In a letter of notification obtained by Rural Press from Marks and Spencer, the company states: "...the 2010 deadline is not negotiable and loss of confidence in M&S wool products could well lead to widespread customer boycotting and loss of revenue for the whole supply chain."

The statement listed that all wool bought for its menswear business would come from non-mulesed sources – "either Australian non-mulesed or from areas such as South Africa where mulesing does not occur".

Woolproducers executive producer Greg Weller said any loss of market share from one of Australia's Merino wool customers would be disappointing.

"The world has come to us with their concerns about an industry practice, and in a short period of time we have given choice through national declaration, and choice for growers through alternatives and through pain relief," Mr Weller said.

In last month's AWEX mulesing status report, 11,167 bales were declared as either ceased mulesed, non-mulesed or pain relief, down from 13,975 in February this year.

In the year to date figures 42,581 kilograms of non-mulesed wool had been tested.

TMC's knitwear manager Mark Brooks is expected to secure wool orders for the TMC pool this week, amid discussion about its non-mulesed Merino brand platform.

TMC has extended its eastern Australian agent base with Ruralco's Rodwells and WISS joining Lempriere Fox and Lillie last month.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
I think the drought is the contributing factor that the amount of non-mulesed wool has dropped, not anything that producers have done to increase mulesing. I have gone from 2500 non mulesed sheep to 1000 because of the drought and I am sure that I am not the only one.
Posted by Helen Clark, 18/06/2009 9:24:14 AM
Are the client's expectations going to be met or will a number of Australian producers continue to 'stand in the corner holding their breath turning blue'? Those who meet the clients' expectations will sell product, those who don't can go broke. Forget AWI; forget Merriman et al arguing about whether mulesing can end. The clients don’t have to buy wool from mulesed sheep.
Posted by Observant, 18/06/2009 10:08:06 AM
Government and farmers of Australia, you are on notice! Get on with the ban on mulesing as you promised (2010). If you don't/can't you will severely damange a valuable export earner. And M&S being such a famous brand, many other companies are likely to follow suit.
Posted by OCP, 18/06/2009 11:00:39 AM
Just this week, Wally and his AWI entourage have been living it up in Europe (at woolgrowers' expense), trying to defend their inaction and delaying tactics. We have the crazy situation where a stud breeder from Australia, backed by an unrepresentative mob called AWGA, is trying to dictate to major retailers what wool they should buy. Talk about arrogance. Not surprisingly, the retailers have said 'go jump' and are looking for wool from other countries.

It is time for AWI and Wally in particular to stop trying to deny reality. The world wants non-mulesed wool. All the spin about trisolfen and sheep being better treated than kids in poor countries (a sick, sick, comparison by the way) doesn't stop the fact that AWI's actions in denying the 2010 deadline and trying to bluff their way through could be the final nail in the wool industry's coffin.

Posted by Sir George, 18/06/2009 12:22:26 PM
To date there is no better alternative!!! Would you all prefer sheep to be dying a slow and painful death in the paddock due to flystrike?????
Posted by wombat, 18/06/2009 1:34:33 PM
Merino sheep must be mulesed until there is an effective alternative - there is no other practical answer.
Posted by Merino wether., 18/06/2009 7:45:06 PM
It's an accurate comparison George. Kids in India living on garbage dumps. Hutus and Tutsy with arms hacked off in Africa. How many starve to death under Mugabe or in the horn of Africa? What ever people's view on animal lib, man's inhumanity to man is far worse.
Posted by THE FARMER, 18/06/2009 11:38:50 PM
There is a very simple message that most woolgrowers can't seem to understand. I'll try to phrase the message as simply as possible. Unless the wool is from un-mulesed sheep, the world doesn't want your wool. If it's a case of mulesing or fly-strike, then Australian wool is redundant. The long-suffering Australian wool industry is finally in its death throws. Let me assure you, there are few people who care.
Posted by Bob, 19/06/2009 6:54:57 AM
I read in today's Courier Mail [online] that PETA are up in arms over President Obama swatting a fly - this shows how pathetically ridiculous these people are. They sent him a "humane fly trap" so the flies caught inside a residence could be released outside. I wonder if this applies also to cockroaches, rats, mice, poisonous spiders etc? Most of these pests are carriers of disease & filth, one wonders exactly what PETA would see as an ideal world. There is no alternative to mulesing as yet for our operation, as our country is certified organic, with our cattle fully certified, and plans for sheep & wool to be certified as well. So we can't have our country littered with plastic clips, apart from the organic aspect, could be the latest cause of rumen impaction as curious young cattle will eat anything. Chucking more chemical on sheep isn't an option either [think of all those poor flies & their cute little maggot babies that would suffer!] & after many years of culling sheep with a bare anything, I doubt we would be rushing into that. Of course most graziers select their sheep for fly resistance, but mulesing has been proven to be the single most effective tool against flystrike. Picture this - it's bucketed down rain for a week, the creeks are flooding, the country has turned into a giant marshmallow that you can't walk on, it's warm & humid & you have 5000 unmulesed ewes scattered over 50,000 acres in the middle of lambing. Makes me break out in a cold sweat.
Posted by ct, 19/06/2009 10:42:06 AM
70% of the clip goes to China. The Chinese don't care if sheep are mulesed or not. If returns don't increase we'll just run Dorpers. 60 grand+ a year from my property alone that won't go in wages to the shearing industry. And that'll happen if mulesing is banned without something to take it's place. It's cruel not to mules.
Posted by Brindi, 19/06/2009 5:09:57 PM
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
MULTIMEDIA
16 June, 2009
15 June, 2009
POLL
Q: Has the deregulation of the wheat industry's single desk marketing system been beneficial to grain growers?

Yes
(25.4%)

No
(50.4%)

It's too soon to tell
(24.2%)

Total Votes: 476
Poll Date: 14 June, 2009

Most popular articles

Advertisement

Irwin Hunter 160x160


Farm Weekly







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...