News 
 State News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Redman making rash decisions on GM: Greens 

Redman making rash decisions on GM: Greens

21 Aug, 2009 07:27 AM
The Greens have attacked Western Australian Agricultural Minister Terry Redman's attitude to genetically modified crops, following the Minister's return from his fact-finding visit to Canada.

Federal Greens Senator Rachel Siewert says regulation of GM crops and foods is "grossly inadequate" and that the moratorium should be maintained.

"There are serious concerns about Australia's labelling laws in relation to GM items in crops - even if we could get past the current deadlock on a national labelling scheme, it would take two years or more to implement," Sen Siewert said.

"All the while, our agricultural sector is being contaminated."

Sen Siewert claims it does not make economic sense to adopt GM technologies.

"GM canola costs 15 per cent more to grow than conventional canola - once the additional cost of the seed, inputs, user fee and end point royalty fees are taken into account - and independent trials have shown GM canola yields 10pc less than non-GM varieties," she said.

Greens WA MLC Lynn MacLaren also questioned the diversity of views the Minister sought out on his trip.

"We have serious concerns that the Minister has not truly canvassed the issue," she said.

"You have to question exactly who Mr Redman has met with, to come back with such a positive view of GM crops.

"It would appear that he didn’t talk to those in Canada who strongly oppose GM crops.

"We've already seen a number of shires in the south-west and Great Southern voting to ban GM crops - why won't the Minister listen to these people and maintain WA's proud GM-free status?"

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
There's only one explanation for Redman & the Liberal's ridiculous pro-GM stance - they are sold out to the mega GM corporations!
Posted by John, 21/08/2009 2:16:57 PM, on Farm Weekly
Minister Redman is being carried away by the flattery of the GM industry publicity machine, but don't blame him too much. The lack of balance in his judgement of GM crops is simply an indication of his susceptibility to this sort of treatment. There are still some scientists in this country who have not been influenced by Monsanto, not many of course, but enough to point out the obvious failure of GM to transform the agricultural industry. As Alan Chartres has said, 25 years and billions of dollars spent and they still haven't produced bountiful crops or drought resistant plants. Disaster in Argentina, thrown out of Indonesia, hated in India, Redman is one of the few friends they have left. The tragedy is he is an Australian Minister for Agriculture! Farcical really!
Posted by creeker, 21/08/2009 2:20:16 PM, on Farm Weekly
Redman is grossly irresponsible, not only to Western Australians, but to all Australians. Anyone with an ounce of common sense realises the dangers that GM pose to the entire human race. Aside from all the obvious dangers with these insidious crops, it would be suicidal to rely on such a narrow varietal base. Wake up Redman you have been conned big time and you should know better.
Posted by ggwagga, 21/08/2009 3:53:20 PM, on Farm Weekly
I think it is time the minister listened to & represented those who voted him in. Surely this should be his first & only motive.
Posted by richard, 22/08/2009 7:32:19 AM, on Farm Weekly
Redman also wants to gut the GM Crops Free Areas Act which sets out a process to enable the WA state government to declare all or part of the state either a GM or GM-free zone, for marketing reasons. This law is part of the national GM regulatory system, with similar Acts in all Australian states and territories, under a joint agreement with the Commonwealth government. For five years until 2008, GM canola was banned throughout Australia. The whole of WA was then a GM-free zone. South Australia, Tasmania and the ACT continue to be GM-free under their laws, reflecting the views of most farmers and shoppers everywhere. Sensibly, the WA Act requires the Agriculture Minister to refer back to Parliament any plan to allow commercial GM crops to be grown. But this pro-GM government wants no discussion. It will neuter the Act so Minister Redman has the sole power to approve GM crops, without review. Watering down the Act would be unfair, unjust and undemocratic. The Act should be kept intact so that due process can protect public health, the environment and WA’s precious export markets in Asia and Europe.
Posted by Bob Phelps, 22/08/2009 10:52:18 AM, on Farm Weekly
We have a right to eat and farm GM free. I want these rights protected and upheld. All the problems we face in global warming and climate change can be solved by permaculture. However permaculture, bio dynamic and organic farming are threatened by the genes flowing from GM trials. Corrupt scientists say this won't happen, but they published papers in 2001 saying it could. By 2003 they had been got at it seems. They published new studies which showed gene flow was negligible (failing to disclose that Monsanto partly funded this research) and now continually state that crosses between GM and non GM will rarely happen and crosses between weedy relatives and GM canola will be sterile. This is not true. In news this week a Ph D student is crossing canola with wild mustard to improve its vigour. Crop Watch in Victoria has measured contamination in Non GM canola large distances from GM canola which according to DAFWA experts is "highly unlikey to happen". The contamination of our environment with transgenes which cause sickness when eaten is threatening permaculture whose main weapon against climate change is home food production.
Posted by Merri Bee, 22/08/2009 11:00:51 AM, on Farm Weekly
Typical, the knit your own under wear crowd spruiking doomsday scenios. Minister Redman would be negligant to his farmers if he didn't expolore GM crops and hold a trial. I have seen first-hand the benifits of RR canola and believe it will fit into my farming system very well. I have just met with two Japanese grain buyers who will happily purchace WA's GM canola. GM crops will make the WA wheatbelt more sustainable and offfer choice. The partnership govt will I believe allow GM canola to be grown again in WA next year, orders for 50,000ha have already been recieved by seed companies and I bet the sky won't fall in.
Posted by allmattergreen, 24/08/2009 6:58:51 AM, on Farm Weekly
Rash, arrogant and reckless....what is the man thinking? No markets are asking for GM, consumers are rejecting it and demanding GM labelling as they do not trust those who tell us that it is safe, and still we are having it thrust upon us and entering the food chain untested and unlabelled. The Act needs to be strengthened, not weakened.
Posted by Hebe, 24/08/2009 9:34:38 AM, on Farm Weekly
The Greens are really discrediting themselves on this issue. By taking a philosophical and non-scientific approach to the treatment of GM crops they are moving themselves further away from sensible policy debate on agriculture and the environment.
Posted by southwestfarmer, 24/08/2009 11:22:25 AM, on Farm Weekly
What are you thinking Redman and the stupid farmers that are playing Russian roulette with our lives, our kids future and our future agricultual sustanability? Every farmer or neighbour of a GM farmer should voice their disgust at them for taking the road they have taken, because it is only their greed they are worried about, not anything or anyone else. So next time you see them let them know how you feel and keep WA GM free. Let's have a referendum.
Posted by gm(greedy mungrels), 30/08/2009 10:49:43 PM, on Farm Weekly
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Most popular articles

Advertisement

Irwin Hunter 160x160


Farm Weekly







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...