News 
 State News 
 Grains and Cropping 
 General 
 Tour confirms Redman's GM stance 

Tour confirms Redman's GM stance

28 Jul, 2009 09:29 AM
AGRICULTURE and Food Minister Terry Redman has returned home from his fact finding mission to the United States and Canada with a strong affirmation of the State Government's decision to give genetically modified (GM) crop trials the green light in WA this season.

The trip also helped Mr Redman gain a deeper perspective on the need to enhance the progress of biotechnology in WA and stimulate research and development of GM wheat.

Walking into flourishing corn crops mid season in North America, Mr Redman met with a range of agricultural industry stakeholders on the two-week tour.

His aim was to gather information on two target issues, GM crops and biofuels, with climate change another important topic on the periphery.

The trip will also provide evidence for the current review of the GM Crops Free Act, which prohibits the commercial production of GM crops in WA.

"There was nothing substantial that I saw over there on my trip which is sending me signals which says we are not heading down a reasonable path that is going to provide options and choices for our farmers like they have in the US and Canada," Mr Redman said.

"If anything they were surprised we are taking this level of caution.

"GM canola has gone gangbusters and they are not seeing any measurable issues with getting those products into their key markets."

In Washington, Mr Redman met with officials from the American Farm Bureau, which represents about six million farmers.

He said the bureau was concerned about climate change and its impact on farmers and was also supportive of GMs and biofuels.

However, he said they had trouble understanding why Australia had lingering concerns over the use of GM crops.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Come now, this is a biased viewpoint from Redman. He was so blinkered with the GM hype that he did not even consider visiting GM-free people during this tour and discover the problems with GM. At least two written invitations were issued to Redman by the National Farmers Union (including the Saskatchewan Organic Directorate) and Percy Schmeiser (who was sued by Monsanto), to meet in Saskatoon when he visited. Redman agreed only to a phone call with NFU President Terry Boehm, which could just as well have been made from Australia. "This does not constitute balanced fact-finding on gene manipulation," Bob Phelps says. Redman specifically mentions visiting Missouri and Saskatchewan which happens to be Monsanto's world headquarters and are in St. Louis Missouri and his hosts in Canada were likely the Canola Council of Canada which is not a farmers organisation. This is a farce when Redman is using the taxpayers money to go on a marketing meeting with Monsanto.
Posted by Concerned, 29/07/2009 6:50:47 AM, on Farm Weekly
Minister Redman went to America to find himself right. Did anyone expect he would find himself wrong? A crop resistant to glyphosate allowing and requiring high levels of spray application is clearly just another step toward more glyphosate reistant weeds. Can there be any other outcome?
Posted by Peter, 29/07/2009 8:47:04 AM, on Farm Weekly
Concerned, you are quite right to be. Redman didn't even ring Terry Boehm after saying he would - so heard nothing but pro-GE rhetoric on his trip to Canada. Of course the Canadians want WA to grow GE canola. At the moment WA has a marketing advantage over Canada because of its GE free status. WA adopting GE canola will help Canada no end. Canada completely lost its canola exports to Europe as a result of adopting GE canola and WA stands to do the same if it goes down the GE path. And all this for a tecnology with no proven benefits. GE canola costs 15% more to grow than conventional canola and doesn't yield any more. In fact, in last year's GRDC trials the best yielding GE canola variety yielded 10% less than the best yielding conventional variety. By embracing GE canola Redman will be ignoring the advice of Japanese trade advisors and throwing away WA's key marketing advantage. His ignorance and arrogance is truly astounding.
Posted by Lou, 29/07/2009 10:37:54 AM, on Farm Weekly
Apparently Terry Redman did not even phone Terry Boehm. Who did Terry Redman visit? I would like to see his full itinerary.
Posted by Fran, 29/07/2009 10:43:50 AM, on Farm Weekly
Pro GM minister visits pro GM farmers and pro GM industries and returns with GM thumbs up....didn't see that one coming, did we?
Posted by Hebe, 29/07/2009 10:44:38 AM, on Farm Weekly
And Hebe, doing it on our taxpayer dollars. Have any of you noticed that as soon as the trial reports were out from the GRDC the head of the GRDC was replaced with a pro-GM advocate? Let's see the truth coming out this year with that happening.
Posted by Concerned, 29/07/2009 1:40:51 PM, on Farm Weekly
Did Minister Redman visit Disneyland while he was in the US/Canada? If not, why not? That is where people go when they want to entertain the kids or make a "study" which is a Claytons study. Remember those? That's the study you have, when you're not having a study. How can he claim to have studied something in which he has only spoken to one side of the issue? His biography reads like that of a guy with a little knowledge about a lot of things but not a great deal about anything, and this trip to Canada/US confirms this. One thing for sure, he knows nothing about genetically modified crops. Ask him about the Showa Denko Tryptophan disaster. Monsanto won't mention it. Nobody in the GM business want to talk about it. And why not, you might ask? Because 37 people died and fifteen hundred were disabled, that's why! Monsanto will duck and weave but they can't deny the courts final remarks, after a ten-year trial. "There is little doubt that the cause was the introduction of the genetically modified plant material " No sane politician would support a corporation with the reputation of Monsanto and its cohorts, around the world. Unless their name is Redman---One Eyed Redman
Posted by creeker, 29/07/2009 4:30:27 PM, on Farm Weekly
Just goes to show that Monsanto and co are bed fellows with many of our so called 'leaders'. As Dr Shiv Chopra's whistleblowing book is called = 'Corruption to the core'. These blinded people in power are undertaking a terrible mistake on humanity. At least they'll have their retirement funds sorted.
Posted by brett sanders, 29/07/2009 4:44:12 PM, on Farm Weekly
Shame on Colin Bettles for such a biased report. So many people in on the GM scam, surley one of the greatest cons of all time.
Posted by Merri Bee, 29/07/2009 5:47:07 PM, on Farm Weekly
Minister Redman is frantic to justify his stance on GM so has to tell us how wonderful everything is overseas. Here in WA opposition to this government's GM policy is growing as more people educate themselves on just what we could lose in WA by going to GM crops. We will lose economically and environmentally without even considering the long term health problems we could be inflicting on future generations if we continue on this path of playing with the bully boys of the GM industry.
Posted by alison, 29/07/2009 6:05:27 PM, on Farm Weekly
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Agriculture and Food Minister Terry Redman talks with Canadian farmers during his recent trip to the US and Canada.
Agriculture and Food Minister Terry Redman talks with Canadian farmers during his recent trip to the US and Canada.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES

Most popular articles

Advertisement

Irwin Hunter 160x160


Farm Weekly







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...