News 
 State News 
 Livestock 
 Cattle 
 Ludwig on front foot as Liberals claim Indonesian payback for live export ban 

Ludwig on front foot as Liberals claim Indonesian payback for live export ban

23 Dec, 2011 02:00 AM
FEDERAL Agriculture Minister Joe Ludwig has denied the decision from the Indonesian Government to cut its live cattle import quota had anything to do with the ban he put in place in June.

Mr Ludwig said in a statement to Farm Weekly this week the claims by the Opposition that the decision from the Indonesian Agriculture Minister Suswono was payback for the live cattle export ban to Indonesia he imposed, were untrue.

"What the Coalition has said is unnecessary, untrue and very damaging for the confidence of the Australian industry," Mr Ludwig said.

"It shows that the Opposition leader Tony Abbott, John Cobb and others, are willing to play on peoples' fears and talk down the entire industry simply to score some cheap political points.

'If the Coalition had got its way, no action would ever have been taken to improve animal welfare, or to secure a long term future for the industry."

Mr Ludwig said the Australian Government remained committed to the live export trade and the decision by Minister Suswono was based on the country's move towards self-sufficiency.

"Decisions about import quotas are a matter for the Indonesian Government," he said.

"Over recent years there has been considerable variation in the number of permits issued.

"Indonesia has repeatedly stated its intention to move towards self-sufficiency in beef production."

Mr Ludwig said the fluctuations in import permits reflected an attempt to balance Indonesia's ambition with the need to supply enough cattle to meet local demand.

"I understand import quotas for Indonesia apply to all countries, not just Australia," he said.

"Last week I discussed this matter with industry and with my State counterparts, all of whom are well aware variations are part and parcel of trading in all markets.

"The Australian Government is actively working with the Indonesian Government to support this mutually beneficial trade now and into the future.

"Australia has already had success in opening and expanding live cattle markets in Vietnam, Turkey and Egypt, and the Gillard Government and industry will continue to pursue new trade avenues."

WA Agriculture Minister Terry Redman said he was waiting for more information from Mr Ludwig before he would make a comment on the import cuts.

Mr Redman did tell Farm Weekly the import cuts would have a massive impact on WA and said he had built up a strong relationship with Indonesia.

"It is my view, while I fully appreciate Mr Suswono making the point that Indonesia is still heading towards self-sufficiency, which is still a challenging target for them, that Australia and WA would be their preferred choice for stock," Mr Redman said.

"I am waiting to get the feedback on the quality of the information from Mr Ludwig but we need to bear in mind that next year the issuant of import quotas will be handled by the Minister of Trade not the Minister of Agriculture in Indonesia.

"I respect Indonesia's move towards self-sufficiency and it comes as no surprise because they mentioned it to me when I was there and if there is a cut in Indonesia's imports, then I believe WA is very capable to supply what Indonesia needs."

Mr Redman said he didn't believe the ban on live cattle exports to Indonesia in June played a major role in Mr Suswono's decision.

"I don't believe the ban was a direct factor in the import cuts but it certainly hasn't helped," he said.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
We will never 'outbully the bully'. Whatever your politics on animal welfare may be, knee jerk reactions will rarely get an acceptabte outcome. Come on Joe and use a little diplomacy next time as we your electors expect you to do because that big stick you are wielding is only a small twig in our geographic region.
Posted by stan SSS, 23/12/2011 6:03:52 AM, on Farm Weekly
Indonesia has never , and probably will never , make a decision about anything in the interests of anyone else except Indonesia . There's really not a lot to discuss here from that point of view .
Posted by Real Deal, 23/12/2011 5:56:53 PM, on Farm Weekly
I guess the Indonesians have had a gutful of Australians demeaning them at every opportunity, Indonesia is a very poor and populous country that is starting to make head roads into the modern world as it embraces democracy and if we don’t treat them with respect and due regard they will simply build relationships with other countries as they continue to develop into a modern wealthy economy
Posted by what the, 24/12/2011 8:45:11 AM, on Farm Weekly
Ludwig is trying to hook off the front foot and is getting hit in the jatz crackers .
Posted by THE FARMER, 27/12/2011 9:10:22 AM, on Farm Weekly

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Federal Agriculture Minister Joe Ludwig has denied the decision from the Indonesian Government to cut its live cattle import quota had anything to do with the ban he put in place in June.
Federal Agriculture Minister Joe Ludwig has denied the decision from the Indonesian Government to cut its live cattle import quota had anything to do with the ban he put in place in June.

Most popular articles


Irwin Hunter 160x160


Farm Weekly







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...